WELCOME
  • Home
  • Same City A New Musical by Mark Pitt
  • Sendflowers.florist
  • Much Ado at the RSC Stratford
  • Brighton Beach Memoirs, Rugby Theatre
  • The House Party, Chichester Festival
  • Things I Know to be True Loft Theatre
  • Two Pints, Belgrade B2
  • Frankenstein Talisman Theatre
  • An Inspector Calls, UK Tour
  • Enchanted April Talisman Theatre
  • Edward II at the RSC
  • Handbagged at The Belgrade Theatre
  • Little Women, National Tour
  • The Southbury Child: Criterion Theatre
  • Mark Pitt Biography
  • Enchanted April at The Talisman Theatre
  • It's a Wonderful Life at The Priory Theatre
  • Spring Awakening, Loft Theatre
  • Ladies Unleashed The Priory Theatre
  • Present Laughter Talisman Theatre
  • Romeo and Juliet Belgrade Theatre
  • Constellations. Loft Theatre Review
  • VIDEOS
  • CONTACT INFO
  • Medea - Loft Theatre
  • Sleeping Beauty, The Priory Theatre
  • Operation Mincemeat, West End
  • Glorious at The Loft Theatre
  • Never the Sinner: Talisman
  • Mosquitoes at the Loft
  • The Addams Family at The Priory
  • Uncle Vanya at The Loft Theatre
  • Sweeney Todd at the Criterion Theatre
  • FEATURE YOUR THEATRE
  • Theatre Preview 2025
  • Pre-Casting in Theatre
  • Are Theatres Welcoming?
  • Criterion's Curious Incident
  • FoCAL Cumming. Forsyth County, GA

To Pre-Cast a Show, or Not?

January 2025

The Truth About Pre-Casting in Theatre

Theatres that claim they do not "pre-cast" productions may, perhaps, be stretching the truth. Over the past few months, I have spoken to several directors, all of whom vehemently deny the practice. However, I remain sceptical. It is human nature to want to produce the best possible work, and if that means collaborating with trusted, talented actors, then so be it.

But why is pre-casting such a sensitive topic? The modern expectation is one of equal opportunity, which is undeniably a good thing. Yet, I know of at least one theatre in the area that pre-cast—at least partially—a production, despite denying that this was their policy. Personally, I see no issue with it. If I wanted to work with a particular performer, I would let them know in advance. If they accepted a role, I would be transparent about it in the audition notice—stating clearly that ‘Role X’ has already been cast. What harm is there in that?

In fact, some theatres choose plays with casting already in mind, particularly when it comes to demanding lead roles. This is especially true for Shakespearean productions—one doesn’t announce Macbeth without an actor in mind for the title role. Similarly, in musical theatre, companies must have a sense of their available talent before selecting a show. Yet, in today’s climate of fairness and inclusivity, theatres must be seen to be holding open auditions, even if these do not always yield new talent. More often than not, seasoned actors will continue to dominate the stage over unknowns.

Recently, I watched an interview with a female performer from a small theatre. She raised some thought-provoking points. One of her main frustrations was the existence of cliques in community theatre, making it difficult for newcomers to break in. She also noted that the same actors were repeatedly cast in leading roles—even when their performances were less than stellar. Nepotism, she suggested, played a significant role in the casting process. That said, the company she referred to was not as large as some of the Warwickshire theatres covered on this site. Smaller towns simply have fewer performers to choose from. Amateur theatre, like most clubs, has long-standing, established members as well as eager newcomers. Perhaps the best approach for an aspiring actor is to spend time working backstage or attending social events at the theatre—getting their face and personality known. But then, what if a new performer is actually more suited to a role than a veteran? Without open auditions, how would a theatre ever know? Taking a chance on fresh talent can sometimes pay off spectacularly—other times, it may fall flat. Either way, one thing is certain: theatres will always have their favourite performers.

I have been pre-cast in both amateur and professional productions. In the former, I earned my place by working my way up from smaller roles. In the latter, I was cast in a farce based on my previous success in a similar production. That farce happened to be Don’t Dress for Dinner, a West End hit that, although originally French, is traditionally performed with British accents. Being British in the USA likely worked to my advantage—especially in a smaller acting pool like Atlanta, compared to London or New York.

In the end, I believe pre-casting is a natural part of the theatre world. Directors, like anyone else, prefer working with people they trust—actors who are skilled, reliable, and, in many cases, friends. Open auditions are valuable, but they inevitably attract hopefuls who may not yet be ready for the stage. Is that a waste of time? Perhaps. But sometimes, auditions unearth hidden gems—future stars waiting for their chance to shine. The debate over pre-casting will no doubt continue. 
​
Happy casting (or pre-casting!).

To comment on this article, please click here. We reserve the right to publish opinions but will not publish names, unless authorised to do so. 

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Same City A New Musical by Mark Pitt
  • Sendflowers.florist
  • Much Ado at the RSC Stratford
  • Brighton Beach Memoirs, Rugby Theatre
  • The House Party, Chichester Festival
  • Things I Know to be True Loft Theatre
  • Two Pints, Belgrade B2
  • Frankenstein Talisman Theatre
  • An Inspector Calls, UK Tour
  • Enchanted April Talisman Theatre
  • Edward II at the RSC
  • Handbagged at The Belgrade Theatre
  • Little Women, National Tour
  • The Southbury Child: Criterion Theatre
  • Mark Pitt Biography
  • Enchanted April at The Talisman Theatre
  • It's a Wonderful Life at The Priory Theatre
  • Spring Awakening, Loft Theatre
  • Ladies Unleashed The Priory Theatre
  • Present Laughter Talisman Theatre
  • Romeo and Juliet Belgrade Theatre
  • Constellations. Loft Theatre Review
  • VIDEOS
  • CONTACT INFO
  • Medea - Loft Theatre
  • Sleeping Beauty, The Priory Theatre
  • Operation Mincemeat, West End
  • Glorious at The Loft Theatre
  • Never the Sinner: Talisman
  • Mosquitoes at the Loft
  • The Addams Family at The Priory
  • Uncle Vanya at The Loft Theatre
  • Sweeney Todd at the Criterion Theatre
  • FEATURE YOUR THEATRE
  • Theatre Preview 2025
  • Pre-Casting in Theatre
  • Are Theatres Welcoming?
  • Criterion's Curious Incident
  • FoCAL Cumming. Forsyth County, GA